Updated Reviewed quarterly
JEPI vs SCHD: Income ETF Showdown
JEPI
TER 0.35% · Yield 7.5% · Monthly
SCHD
TER 0.06% · Yield 3.5% · Quarterly
High current yield or growing dividends? Two very different approaches to income investing.
Key Difference
JEPI offers higher current yield (~7%+) through covered call strategies. SCHD focuses on dividend growth (~3.5% yield) with quality dividend-paying stocks. Different investors may prioritise immediate income vs long-term dividend growth depending on their circumstances.
Fundamentally Different Strategies
JEPI - Maximum Current Income
Uses covered call options to generate high income:
- ✓ ~7.5% yield paid monthly
- ✓ Lower volatility than S&P 500
- ✗ Capped upside in bull markets
- ✗ Income can vary month to month
SCHD - Dividend Growth
Invests in quality dividend growers:
- ✓ ~3.5% yield growing ~12%/year
- ✓ Full upside participation
- ✓ Higher total returns historically
- ✗ Lower current income
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | JEPI | SCHD |
|---|---|---|
| Current Yield | ~7.5% | ~3.5% |
| Distribution Frequency | Monthly | Quarterly |
| Expense Ratio | 0.35% | 0.06% |
| Growth Potential | Limited (capped) | Full upside |
| Dividend Growth | Variable | ~12%/year |
| Typical Use | Current income needs | Long-term wealth building |
Income Comparison: $100,000 NZD Invested
JEPI - Year 1
$7,500/year
~$625/month in income
Income may decrease over time if market rises (opportunity cost)
SCHD - Year 1
$3,500/year
~$290/month in income
But dividends grow ~12%/year → $11,000+/year by year 10
The Crossover Point
If SCHD's dividends grow at 12%/year, it will match JEPI's income in about 7-8 years, then surpass it. If you have a long time horizon, SCHD's growing income becomes more valuable.
For New Zealand Investors
Tax on Higher Yield (JEPI)
JEPI's 7.5% yield means more dividends subject to 15% US withholding. On $100,000, that's ~$1,125/year withheld vs ~$525 for SCHD.
FIF Considerations
SCHD's higher total returns may result in more FIF tax under the CV method. JEPI's lower growth could mean lower FIF under FDR method.
NZD Income Volatility
Both pay in USD. JEPI's higher yield means NZD/USD exchange rate fluctuations have bigger impact on your actual income in NZ dollars.
Key Differences
JEPI Characteristics
- Higher current yield (~7.5%)
- Monthly distributions
- Lower volatility, but capped upside
- Higher expense ratio (0.35%)
SCHD Characteristics
- Lower current yield (~3.5%) with historical dividend growth
- Full upside market participation
- Lower expense ratio (0.06%)
- Quality-screened holdings
These are general product characteristics, not recommendations. Consult a licensed financial adviser to assess suitability for your circumstances.
Learn More About These ETFs
Both ETFs available on NZ investment platforms
Related to JEPI vs SCHD
JEPI ETF detail
Full JEPI guide for NZ investors.
SCHD ETF detail
Full SCHD guide for NZ investors.
SCHD vs VYM
Two dividend-growth ETFs head-to-head.
Best dividend ETFs for NZ
Curated dividend-income picks.
NZ-listed dividend ETFs (PIE-tax)
NZX-listed alternatives without FIF.
How to buy US ETFs from NZ
Platforms supporting JEPI + SCHD.